If A Comedic Batman Were Made Today, Who Would You Cast?

[Gothamite]

john goodman as king tut

martin short as the mad hatter

These two are exactly the one that I choose !

[Gothamite]

Martin Short with the exact same outfit than in Alice in Wonderland ( 1999 ) with Tina Majorino !:)

[High C]

I think Joan Collins, at age 79, would be a PERFECT Black Widow!

[4theboids]

John Lithgow as Commissioner Gordon

Bette Midler would be a GREAT Marsha for sure!

Barry Manilow as Chandell

Julia Louise Dreyfuss as Batgirl (she'd NEVER make a good Catwoman)

[Riddlersgurl]

She also wouldn't make a good Batgirl.

A really comedic Catwoman? Fran Drescher.

Okay, put the torches away and let me explain.

If she's not using her Fran Fine voice, she's a very good actress, and very funny. Not to mention she's got a figure I'd give my eyeteeth to have.

[mattman]

If Batman was on now and I was responsible for casting here goes,

Batman- Seasons 1-4 Matthew Fox
Seasons 5-7 Noah Wyle
Season 6- Present Brian Thomas Smith
Commissioner Gordon- Adam West
Chief O 'Hara- Colm Meaney
The Joker- Javier Bardem/ Ashton Kutcher
The Riddler- Jim Parsons
Lola Lasagne- Joan Rivers
Catwoman- Katy Mixon
Mr.Freeze- Patrick Stewart
The Penguin- Simon Helberg
Poison Ivy- Joanne Kelly
King Tut- Peter Kay
The Bookworm- John Galecki
Boss Biggis- George Wendt
The Scarecrow- Christopher Ecclestone
Maxin Zeus- Sir Anthony Hopkins
Shame- Rich Hall
Two Face- Alec Baldwin
False Face- ? (John Lithgow)

More on the way- what do you think?

[mattman]

Me again, hello by the way from Essex in England. Hope everybody is well
Part two of my current Batman casting

Warden Crichton-Dean Stockwell
Harley Quinn- Kaley Cuoco
Killer Croc- Brad Garrett
Music Meister-Neil Patrick Harris
James Gordon jnr- James Franco
Mayor Linseed -Burt Ward
Condiment King- Jon Cryer
The Puzzler- David Hyde Pearce
Count Vertigo- Hugh Bonnerville
Professor Hugo Strange- Sir Ian McKellen
Egghead- Kelsey Grammar
The Mad Hatter- Michael Sheen
Nora Clavicle- Katherine Heigl

Part 3 will come soon, thoughts ?

[mattman]

If I was responsible for casting of a Batman show today here would be my choices,

Hi,by the way from Essex, England-hope everyone is well,

Batman; Matthew Fox (seasons 1-4)
Noah Wyle (seasons 5-6)
Brian Thomas Smith (7- present)
Warden Crichton; Dean Stockwell
Mayor Lindseed; Burt Ward
Commissioner Gordon; Adam West
Chief O'Hara; Colm Meaney
Alfred; Daniel Lewis
The Joker; Javier Bardem
Ashton Kutcher
The Penguin; Simon Helberg
Count Vertigo; Hugh Bonnerville
The Scarecrow; Christopher Ecclestone
Catwoman; Katy Mixon
Harley Quinn; Kaley Cuoco
The Puzzler; David Hyde Pearce
King Tut; Peter Kay
Mr.Freeze; Patrick Stewart
The Riddler; Jim Parsons
Big Top; Melissa Mc Carthy
Egghead; Kelsey Grammar
Lola Lasagne; Joan Rivers
Poison Ivy; Joanne Kelly
The Bookworm; John Galecki
Killer Croc; Brad Garrett
Music Meister; Neil Patrick Harris
Two Face; Ted Danson
Professor Hugo Strange; Avery Brooks
Maxie Zeus; Sir Anthony Hopkins
Boss Biggis; George Wendt
James Gordon jnr; James Franco
Condiment King; John Cryer
Minerva; Katherine Heigl
Shame; Rich Hall
Marsha; Jane Krakowski
The Mad Hatter; Michael Sheen
Louie the Lilac; Ian Mc Shane
Man Bat; David Tennant
The Clock King; Brent Spiner
The Siren; Jamie Murray
Bane; John Gordon Levitt
False Face; ? ( various throughout the series, inc; Alfred Molina,Pierce Brosnan and even rumoured to be Tom Cruise in season 9)
The Ventriloquist; Simon Pegg
Killer Moth; Ryan Stiles
Lock Up; Colin Salmon
Black Mask; Jonathan Frakes
Ma Parker; Swoosie Kurtz
Hush; Dominc West
The Archer; Drew Carey
The Sandman; Anthony Head
The Minstrel; Alun Cummings
The Cavalier; Steve Coogan
The Film Freak; Martin Short
Black Widow; Joan Collins
Torque; Jon Hamm
Sweet Tooth; Saul Rubinek
Karl Langstrom/Man Bat; Idris lba

Please tell me what you think....
But...be warned....the most despicable is YET to come!!!!!
Same Matt time
Same Matt channel